Volume vs Custom Builder for Your Dual Occupancy

Choosing a builder is one of the first real decisions in a dual occupancy project, and one of the hardest to reverse. Melbourne owners generally choose between two models: a volume builder, working from a range of standard designs, or a custom builder, designing each project around the site and the owner.

Both have their place. Volume builders deliver large numbers of homes efficiently and suit certain sites and budgets well. Custom builders work on fewer projects, with more time spent on each. The right choice depends less on which model is better in general and more on your site, your suburb and what you want the finished homes to achieve.

Before comparing the two, it helps to answer a few questions about your own project:

  • Are you building to sell, to keep, to live in, or a combination?
  • How regular is your site? Is it flat and rectangular, or does it have slope, trees, an easement or an unusual frontage?
  • What do buyers in your street expect, and what are they paying for?
  • How much do you value dealing with the same person from the first meeting through to handover?

Your answers will usually point clearly in one direction.

1. Capitalising correctly for your suburb

This is the question we think matters most, and the one most often overlooked.

A dual occupancy in Camberwell is not the same product as one in Doncaster or Glen Waverley. Buyers in each suburb expect different things: floor area, number of bedrooms, a downstairs master, the quality of finishes, the size of the courtyard, the presence of a second living area. Build below what the local market expects and the homes sell or value at a discount. Build well above it and you spend money the sale price or valuation won't return.

Capitalising correctly means matching the design and specification to the buyers your homes will appeal to when the time comes to sell, whether that is next year or in fifteen years.

A builder who works regularly in your area will generally have a clearer view of this. They will know what comparable homes have sold for, which features buyers have paid a premium for, and which have made little difference. This is not unique to custom builders, but it is harder for a builder working from a statewide range of designs to tailor the product to a particular street.

Your brief comes first

Capitalising correctly does not mean designing to a formula. Most owners come to a project with a clear idea of what they want, particularly if they plan to live in one of the homes. That brief is the starting point.

Our role is to consider your brief alongside what the site and the suburb offer, and to give you clear guidance on:

  • What works well locally: the layouts, sizes and features that buyers in your area respond to.
  • Where the site offers differentiation: north light to the living areas, an outlook to a mature tree, a corner frontage, a fall in the land that allows higher ceilings or a split level. These are the details that set a pair of homes apart from the comparable sales around them.
  • Where to hold back: elements that add cost without adding value for the likely buyer.

If you decide to go beyond what the market will pay for, perhaps a larger kitchen, a pool or a higher specification in the home you plan to keep, that is a legitimate choice. The aim is to make it consciously, knowing it is something you want rather than something the valuation or sales price will neccessarily recover.

2. Designing from the site, not fitting a design to it

Volume builders work from a range of established designs. Most offer options to adjust them: alternative facades, an extra bedroom, a butler's pantry, a different staircase. The underlying plan, however, was drawn before anyone looked at your block.

On a flat, rectangular site with a standard frontage, that approach can work well. Many Melbourne sites are not like that. Established eastern suburbs blocks commonly have:

  • slope across or along the site
  • significant trees with protection zones that limit where you can build
  • easements, often for drainage or sewer, that cannot be built over without approval
  • irregular shapes, narrow frontages or corner positions
  • orientation that puts the obvious living area on the wrong side

A custom builder designs from the site. Orientation, setbacks, overlooking, tree protection zones and services are worked through first, and the homes are planned to make the most of what the site allows. On a difficult site, this is often the difference between a design that gains a planning permit easily and one that needs several rounds of changes.

3. Who you deal with, from first meeting to handover

A volume builder typically involves several people over the life of a project: a sales consultant at the start, a design or pre-construction team, a site supervisor, a customer service team after handover. Each is competent in their own area, but the person who understood your goals at the first meeting is rarely the person on site when decisions need to be made.

A smaller custom builder usually offers continuity. The person you meet at the start is involved at each stage, including design, planning, pricing, construction and handover. That matters most when something unexpected comes up on site, which on any two-dwelling project it will. Decisions are made by someone who knows the history of the project and why it was designed the way it was.

The trade-off is capacity. A custom builder takes on fewer projects at a time, so start dates may need to be planned further ahead.

4. Cost and price certainty

Volume builders benefit from buying power and standardised designs, and their base prices reflect that. The base price, however, is rarely the full cost. Site costs, such as excavation, retaining, drainage, service connections, tree protection and crossovers, are often priced separately once the site has been assessed, along with upgrades from the standard inclusions. On a complex site, the gap between the advertised price and the contract price can be significant.

A custom build is priced on the actual design for the actual site. The starting figure is generally higher, but site-specific costs are part of the price from the beginning rather than added later. For a realistic view of current costs, see our dual occupancy build cost guide.

Whichever builder you choose, compare fixed-price contracts on a like-for-like basis, check what is excluded, and confirm how site costs and provisional sums are treated.

5. Time

Volume builders have well-established systems and can often move from contract to completion quickly on a straightforward site. A custom project usually spends longer in design and planning, because the design is being developed rather than selected.

In practice, the planning permit is the longest stage for most dual occupancies, whichever builder you use. A design developed from the site, with council requirements considered from the outset, can reduce the risk of redesign and delay at that stage. Our dual occupancy development process sets out the typical stages and timeframes.

When a volume builder may suit you

  • Your site is flat, regular and free of major constraints.
  • A standard design from their range fits the site and the local market.
  • Budget is the main priority and you are comfortable with standard inclusions.
  • You are building to rent and are less concerned with differentiation.

When a custom builder may suit you

  • Your site has slope, trees, easements, an irregular shape or a corner position.
  • You are in a suburb where buyers expect a higher level of design and finish.
  • You plan to live in one of the homes and want it designed around how you live.
  • You want one person accountable from the first meeting to handover.
  • You want the design and specification matched to what the homes will sell for.

How we approach dual occupancy at Vector

Vector is a design and build practice focused on dual occupancy and duplex projects across Melbourne's eastern suburbs, including Boroondara, Manningham, Whitehorse and Stonnington. We also develop our own projects, so we approach every design with an eye on how it will sell, as well as how it will live.

We work with established building designers and architects, or with your own designer if you already have one. Each project starts with the site and your brief, and we stay involved from feasibility through to handover.

Our recently completed side-by-side duplex at Vivian Street, Blackburn North shows what that looks like in practice.

Learn more about our dual occupancy design and build service, or book a feasibility review to talk through your site.

Frequently asked questions

Is a custom builder always more expensive than a volume builder? The starting price is generally higher. The difference narrows on complex sites, where a volume builder's site costs and variations can add considerably to the base price. Compare final contract prices, not advertised base prices.

Can a volume builder design a dual occupancy for a sloping or irregular site? Many can adapt their designs, within limits. On a heavily constrained site, adapting a standard plan can lead to compromises in layout, light or yard space that a design developed from the site would avoid.

Can I bring my own architect or building designer to a custom builder? Often, yes. We are happy to work with your designer, or to introduce you to designers we work with regularly.

What does capitalising correctly mean? Building homes whose size, layout and specification match what buyers in your suburb will pay for. Overcapitalising means spending more than the sale price will return; undercapitalising means leaving value behind.

When should I involve a builder? Ideally before you finalise the design, and if possible before you buy the site. Early input on construction cost, services and site constraints can shape the design and avoid redesign later.

Next
Next

Dual Occupancy Development Process Overview